20090209

Answers to Crosaire No. 00001 - 13 Mar 1943

Original title to Irish Times Crossowrd No. 1
Barry, one of our true Crosaire experts, has pointed out that Crosaire puzzles are available online, dating back to 1943!

Access to the online archive of The Irish Times requires a subscription, although free access can be granted at times as a promotion (it’s free right now, through April 6th, 2009, as part of the newspaper's 150th anniversary celebration). I don’t have a subscription today, but used to have one when I was active in family history research. The archive truly is a fabulous resource, and is searchable, right back to 1859.

The very first Irish Times Crossword was published on Saturday, March 13, 1943. If you have a subscription to The Irish Times archives, you can use these links to view Derek Crozier's first crossword in The Irish Times. You can read the whole page, or zoom in on the crossword title, the grid and the clues. The grid was drawn and numbered by hand, and of course the clues themselves were typeset manually. This first crossword was then followed one week later by the second puzzle, becoming a weekly feature every Saturday. There was no mention of the name of the crossword compiler until Saturday, April 3, 1943, when Irish Times Crossword No. 4 introduced Crosaire to his public.

I spent hours today working on “Crosaire No. 1”, and I thoroughly recommend the mental exercise. It truly was a lot of fun.

Crosaire Aria
I don’t think that “Top of the Pops” charts were compiled in Ireland or the UK back in 1943, so I have to go with a US recording. The number one selling record over here in March 1943 was I’ve Heard That Song Before by Harry James and his Orchestra. This particular song, and others by Harry James, feature on the soundtrack of the Woody Allen film Hannah and Her Sisters. Listening to this really does set the mood for puzzling over Crosaire Crossword No. 1 …

The Clue of 1943
1A: Is VALO, and presumably also LOUR (10)
I puzzled over this one for ages, needing letters from the down answers to point me in the right direction. In the end I was left with D-S-R-E-T-O- and began to plug in words that would fit. I noticed that VALO was an anagram of ‘OVAL’, a ‘disc’ perhaps, so I thought the answer might start with DISC- and then play off that anagram somehow. Finally DISCRETION just seemed to fit. I finally noticed that VALO and LOUR were parts of the word ‘valour’, a word linked to DISCRETION in an old idiom. A little more noodling revealed that both VALO and LOUR, in terms of letter count, form the better part of VALOUR. Ah … and now the idiom unlocks the clue: discretion is the better part of valour, as are both VALO and LOUR. This has to be the best clue I have seen in a long time, maybe even since 1943 …

The Lookup of 1943
11A: ANTIPODES
I’ve always thought of Australia and New Zealand as the Antipodes, because of my upbringing in Ireland. It turns out that in more general terms, the antipodes is the name given to the lands and peoples on the opposite side of the earth to you, the speaker. So from here in California, the opposite side of the earth is a spot in the Indian Ocean, with Madagascar the nearest thing to the antipodes for me. It just doesn’t sound right though …

I warn you that it not easy to solve Mr. Crozier’s 1943 clues. I got about ¾ of the way through after a couple of hours work, and then I had to google two answers in order to finish the rest of the puzzle. The answers were indeed published one week later back in 1943, but the answer grid is completely illegible online, so my solution is unverified. Please feel free to leave a comment below, or send me an email, especially if you notice something wrong with my reasoning.

Across
1: DISCRETION

v-a-l-o are the first four letters of ‘valour’, and l-o-u-r are the last four letters. Each is an example of the better, greater, part of ‘valour’. And DISCRETION is the better part of valour as well. I am in awe …
6: SCAR … anagram of “arcs”.
10, 12: STIFF UPPER LIP
11: ANTIPODES

I guessed this one, and then did a look up to verify. I’ve always regarded Australia and New Zealand as the Antipodes, but in more general terms the antipodes refers to lands and peoples on the opposite side of the earth from the speaker.
12: see 10A
13: A-I-RED
An excellent, class A1 (AI) color (RED) = AIRED, exposed to the atmosphere.
15: DRIFTER
A type of fishing boat, and someone who drifts from place to place, a wastrel. Wastrel: what a beautiful word!
17: NAN-KEEN
This is one of the two clues I had to cheat on to get me moving again. Anne (NAN) is enthusiastic (KEEN) = NANKEEN, is a pale, yellowish cloth, originating from Nanjing, China.
19: LAG-GARD
-GARD, almost makes ‘guard’. One who keeps his eye on a convict. And a LAGGARD is one who is lazy.
21: RADICLE
The part of the seed that develops into the root, and it sounds like ‘radical’, a revolutionary.
22: SIEVE … anagram of “is Eve”.
24: PRESUMES
Henry Stanley purportedly uttered the words ‘Doctor Livingstone, I presume?’ And, one who PRESUMES is somewhat pushy.
27: EXISTENCE
“Man’s love is of man’s life a thing apart, ‘tis woman’s whole EXISTENCE”, oft-quoted words from Lord Byron’s Don Juan.
28: ‘T-AIN’T
The Cockney says it is not, ‘t ain’t = TAINT, to make something rancid. Nice clue!
29: T-ASK
Almost “to” (T) + ASK = TASK, work.
30: ASTROLOGER … anagram of “regal roost”.

Down
1: DOSE

Poems, odes, an anagram of DOSE, a medicinal quantity.
2: S-TIPPLING
Lifting the elbow, having a drink, TIPPLING, is almost all of the answer STIPPLING, a way of painting.
3: RIFLE … anagram of “flier”.
4: TRAILER
I wasn’t sure they had movie trailers back in 1943!!
5: OUTSPAN
This is the other clue I had to cheat on. OUTSPAN is a peculiarly South African term for unyoking or unharnessing animals, and has come to mean ‘relax’.
UPDATE: As Liz pointed out below, let's not forget OUTSPAN oranges from South Africa. Remember them?
7: CIDER
I guessed this one, as CIDER is fermented apple juice. The reference is to an old limerick:
There was a young lady of Ryde,
Who ate some green apples and died.
The
apples fermented
Inside the lamented,
And made cider inside her inside.
Delightful …
8: RESIDENCES … anagram of “dire scenes”.
9: SPRAINED
And Mr. Crozier actually tells us this is an anagram of “rinse pad”. How cute!
14: A-DOLE-SCENT
Relief payment (A DOLE) + smell (SCENT) = ADOLESCENT, one who has some growing to do.
16: TRA-VEST-Y
Underwear (VEST) in a TRAY = TRAVESTY, something ludicrous.
18: EXCEEDING
20: DEP-ENDS

A department, cut down to dept., short of tea, losing the “t” on the end (DEP) closes (ENDS) = DEPENDS
21: ROEDEER
I’m not sure about this one, as I would have thought the answer should be two words, ROE DEER. Still, as the antelope said to the gazelle when the boat began to sink … Row, dear! Just hilarious!
23: EMITS … anagram of “Times”.
25: UNTIL
26: STAR

I guessed this one too. The quote is from Shelley’s poem The Desire of the Moth.

7 comments:

Dave D said...

Bill,

The digital archive is normally available only to paid subscribers. As part of the 150 year celebrations, it is being made publicly available up until April 6th, AFAIK. So, if you want to grab that special crossword, you've only until Monday!

Unfortunately, I was born on a Sunday :(

All the best,
Dave

Bill Butler said...

Dave,

Thanks for the information about the Archive promotion.

And Happy April Fools Day ... :o)

Liz said...

Hi Bill

Well that was a challenge and great fun - but needless to say I didn't finish! I just couldn't resist looking at your solutions any longer and I reckon I had spent long enough at it, don't think any more pennies were going to drop! And I certainly will have to do a 'stiff upper lip' on it and not show too much emotion about the fact that I didn't get the 'upper lip' part of that one.....the shame!
'Discretion' took ages despite having seen the 'valour' connection early on....
Got 'outspan' because it fitted and also because of my abiding memory of the Dunnes Stores staff boycott (and subsequent public support for the boycott) on handling S. African produce in the 1980's - OUTSPAN oranges were one of the main targets of the boycott so I figured maybe there was some very bizarre connection!
'Stippling' evaded me; I didn't get the 'lifting the elbow' reference to tippling at all and led myself to believe that the solution would involve some very classical fine-art painting technique - when all the time Mr. Crozier had his eye on Paddy the Painter doing the ceiling (up the ladder and supping a pint of stout?!)
'Laggard' didn't happen either - nor did 'nankeen' for that matter! I was a bit disappointed I didn't get 'nankeen' because I had heard of Nankeen cloth....same ole story! Like yourself Bill I guessed 'cider' and 'star'.

So, at the end of all my efforts (quite a few hours but not sure exactly how long it took cos I went back to it a few times)I was short solutions to four: stippling, Nankeen, laggard and 'upper lip'.

To be honest at the outset I really thought I was going to get very few so I was quite happy with the way things panned out.

By the way, I'd be inclined to agree that 'roedeer' should read 'roe deer' (two words).

Congratulations Bill and though you say your solutions aren't verified I think you have them all present...and correct!

Really enjoyed the challenge - and it certainly was a serious challenge - so thank you Barry for putting out the word....and I'm looking forward to hearing how you got on.

And of course it's all the more amazing when you think that Mr. Crozier is still putting together great crosswords sixty-six years later and into his nineties - what a man! There must be some truth in the widely held belief that solving crossword puzzles helps keep one mentally agile - writing them certainly seems to be serving Mr. Crozier very well.

Enough rambling...

Bill Butler said...

Hi Liz,

It sounds like you got about as far as I did before having to resort to "cheating" :o) Congrats!

Re OUTSPAN
Outspan Oranges! How could I have forgotten. I haven't seen one of those for yonks. Are they still produced? Out here in the land of California Oranges, the South African producers don't show up too often. Well spotted!

Re STIPPLING
I think that STIPPLING might just be a fine art techniques as well, although I prefer your image of Paddy da Vinci throwing it up on his ceiling :o)

Like you, I was somewhat dismayed when I started, and figured I had no chance of getting through this puzzle. It took me about three hours, I'd say, which meant lots of breaks. I was disappointed I had to look up NANKEEN and OUTSPAN, especially now that you have made the OUTSPAN connection for me. But in the end it was very, very satisfying to fill in the last clue. I'm happy to hear that you've given me your vote of confidence that the answers are correct. It's a pity the answer grid from 1943 is illegible.

And I thoroughly agree with you about crosswords keeping the mind active, something that is so important these days it seems. I remember visiting my Dad a couple of years ago and feeling deep regret when my mother told me he didn't do the crossword anymore. I missed the link it provided between us of course, but it was also a statement about his mental well-being, a prophetic statement as it turned out.

Of course doing the Crosaire crossword with a pint beside you, that might be a wee conflict ...

Barry said...

Bill,

I finally finished No. 1, though have taken a lot longer than you did and I did need to consult Google on a few things.

Anyway, I found it challenging, and got a number of answers without fully understanding the clue, so appreciate your notes now to better understand.

I differed on one answer - 23d - I dithered between "emits" and "edits", not being able to decide if it was an anagram or if he was referring to the Times as a newspaper, where edits would change it.

Also I agree that Roe Deer, should be two words. I had to google here, looking up various types of deer.

This puzzle was re-published later (I don't remember the date) along with a small article on Derek Crozier, and I think the answers were typed (upside down!) - so I will check when I'm in the office later today and confirm.

- Barry

Barry said...

Hi Bill,

Well, I was wrong - "emits" is the right answer to 23d.

If anyone is interested, the #1 puzzle was re-printed along with a short article, and the answers in legible format (be careful, they're upside down right under the clues!) on Saturday, January 23rd, 1988 - Page 32.

The archive, still appears to be available without subscription.

This is the direct link, if anyone is interested. http://www.irishtimes.com/newspaper/archive/1988/0123/Pg032.html

Cheers,

Barry

Bill Butler said...

Barry,

Thanks a million for following through on that article written by Mr. Crozier himself. It makes for great reading, and adds a lot of color to what we know about the man. It's a great find. I'll use it to fill in detail in the mini-bio I wrote about Derek.

The most impressive part of the article to me is in the subtitle: "Crosaire has been delighting - and torturing - crossword addicts in this paper for 45 years." That was written back in 1988, over 21 years ago. Derek has been at this for over 66 years ...

Re EMITS
You are indeed right, I think. If EDITS had been the answer, I wouldn't have questioned it at all. I was lucky with EMITS, it seems.

Thanks again for all the great info, Barry, and for finding the reprint and answers to Crosaire No. 00001.